Monthly Archive for February, 2007

Critics of Israel deserve a debate, not demonisation

By Michael Desch The Australian 8 February 2007

Former US president Jimmy Carter’s new book Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid has ignited a firestorm of indignation in some quarters of the American Jewish community.

Continue reading ‘Critics of Israel deserve a debate, not demonisation’

No one has the right to speak for British Jews on Israel and Zionism

By Brian Klug The Guardian (UK) 5 February 2007

If there is one thing on which Jews can agree, it is this: it’s good to argue. Jewish culture has thrived on argument – frank, sincere disagreement – ever since Moses disputed with God. But today an oppressive and unhealthy atmosphere is leading many Jews to feel uncertain about speaking out on Israel and Zionism. People are anxious about contravening an unwritten law on what you can and cannot discuss, may or may not assert.

Continue reading ‘No one has the right to speak for British Jews on Israel and Zionism’